Mr. Rooter Plumbing of South Nashville
97 of 100 analyzed reviews are 5★ (0.96 consistency); honest techs who walked away with no charge when a clog resolved itself.
Why we're cautious
- Over-diagnosis flagged once: $1,000+ full valve replacement quoted for a shower leak fixed by simply tightening the cartridge (1 of 100 reviews)
- One reviewer reports a tech recommended a $1,000+ valve replacement without inspecting the cartridge; a second opinion fixed it by tightening the existing one (1 of 100 reviews)
To be fair
- Honest pricing — Sandro found the blockage had cleared and charged nothing because he 'didn't do anything' (cited in 1 of 100 reviews)
- Professionalism cited in 42 of 100 reviews; repeat customers request specific techs (Robert, Drazon) by name (cited in 2 of 100 reviews)
- Clear step-by-step communication on pricing and solutions (2 communication mentions) (cited in 1 of 100 reviews)
“Great experience. Highly recommended.”
“I had a leak in my shower and a technician came out to diagnose it. He did not open the shower handle or inspect the cartridge, and instead immediately recommended a full valve replacement requiring drywall removal, quoting over $1,000. I later got a second …”
We read 100 of 511 reviews · newest from Dec 2025