Baker Brothers Plumbing, Air & Electric
Excellent emergency response and workmanship, but pricing practices are inconsistent—some jobs feel fair while others trigger sticker shock on basic repairs.
Our sample skews heavily toward critical reviews — it disagrees with the Google average shown above.
Why we're cautious
- Pattern of aggressive upselling on major systems: multiple reviewers report being quoted thousands for attic insulation, duct cleaning, or line replacement without independent verification, later finding the actual issue was minor (3 of 191 reviews)
- High variance in customer experience (34-point spread in dimension scores): wide swing between 5-star emergency jobs and 1-star billing disputes suggests inconsistent quality control or technician accountability (4 of 191 reviews)
- Severe pricing inconsistency: 4 separate reviews cite quotes for simple fixes that appear grossly inflated ($600 for $27 part, $800 for loose connection, $250 for basic wax seal replacement, $12,000 for attic insulation estimate) (4 of 191 reviews)
To be fair
- Fast emergency response: multiple reviewers report same-day or rapid arrival, including Saturday evening emergency service (cited in 4 of 191 reviews)
- Consistently professional and courteous technicians: 13+ reviews specifically praise technician attitude, knowledge, and friendliness by name (cited in 8 of 191 reviews)
- Strong workmanship and efficiency: jobs completed quickly with clean-up, protective measures, and transparent explanations of work performed (cited in 5 of 191 reviews)
“I had a great experience with Baker Brothers Plumbing, Electric & HVAC. The technician was exceptionally nice and very pleasant to work with. He seemed knowledgeable I had a great experience with Baker Brothers Plumbing, Electric & HVAC. The technician was …”
“Called Baker Brothers on the recommendation of a neighbor because of a possible slab leak. Technician came out same day which was great but failed to find the leak. Said we would have to replace the homeowners valve (2100$$) to begin the process of …”
We read 191 of 24,623 reviews · newest from Mar 2026 · BBB A+ accredited