All plumbers
BP

Brenneco Plumbing

Lafayette, IN
4.8(176 reviews)
RESPONSE

Unknown

No response data yet

EMERGENCY

Not Verified

No emergency data in reviews

PRICING

Premium / Upsells

Membership programs detected in reviews

RED FLAGS

3 concerns

Upselling pattern: 1 of 5 reviews explicitly documents pressure to purchase expensive unnecessary equipment; pricing fairness score of 55 indicates inconsistent practices, Quality control inconsistency: long time customer reports recent decline in service standards with improperly completed water heater work, contradicting their earlier positive experiences, upselling concerns

Trust Score: 0/100 · Based on 176 reviews

How they score across what matters

Based on 5 reviews analyzed. Click a row for the quote that best illustrates the score.

What they do well (and don’t)

Green means reviews confirm they’re good at it. Red means reviewers flag issues. Gray means no reviews talk about it yet.

What 176 Reviews Tell Us

Emergency Response

No reviewers specifically mention emergency response times

What To Watch Out For

Aggressive upselling: attempted to sell $2,900 complete sump pump system replacement when customer only needed routine $200-400 battery replacement

Poor follow-up and dismissive customer service: when customer raised concerns about water heater installation quality, company redirected blame rather than addressing the actual technical issue

Inconsistent discount policy: repeat customer was offered discounts on two prior occasions but later told company has a 'no-discount policy'

1 review mentions membership programs or upselling

Upselling pattern: 1 of 5 reviews explicitly documents pressure to purchase expensive unnecessary equipment; pricing fairness score of 55 indicates inconsistent practices

Quality control inconsistency: long time customer reports recent decline in service standards with improperly completed water heater work, contradicting their earlier positive experiences

Upselling concerns

Quality & Professionalism

3 of 5 reviewers praised technician professionalism and friendliness, particularly Mike and Max

Poor follow-up and dismissive customer service: when customer raised concerns about water heater installation quality, company redirected blame rather than addressing the actual technical issue

Communication

Exceptional responsiveness and punctuality: showed up minutes early with quote generated within minutes of departure

Pricing

Competitive pricing when accurate: one reviewer noted rates were competitive with final charges matching initial quote with no surprises

Clean & Professional

Customer reviews

Reviews from Google, Yelp & more

P
Paul Bunch

I'm very happy with the service Brenneco provided to review the cleanout of a sewer line in West Lafayette, and to provide recommendations for a solution. The technician who we met (Mike) was very friendly, knowledgeable of what he was seeing, and thorough in his recommended solution. Very prompt, friendly, showed up a few minutes before the scheduled appointment, and had the quote generated within minutes of getting back in his vehicle. I definitely recommend Brenneco!

A
Andrew Daigle

Max and Mike removed my old water heater and installed a new tank less water heater. They did a good job and were friendly and professional. While I think it was still a little pricey, it was still cheaper than Anderson heating and air conditioning.

C
Cathy Burkey

Our experience with Brenneco began when they were recommended to us by a heating and cooling company in Lafayette that we have been doing business with for over twelve years. When I called to discuss the work we needed to be done, Becky was very helpful and gave us more confidence in our decision to use Brenneco for our plumbing needs. She even matched us with the employee she felt would be most suitable to work with us. When Mike Winger came out to do the work he was professional, courteous and did the work flawlessly. He even fixed some of the original plumbing under our kitchen sink that we were not aware had been installed incorrectly. We would have Mike back to do any future repairs we might need. Brenneco’s rates were very competitive and the final charges were as quoted. No surprises. Brenneco is a 10!

P
Parab

I’ve been a loyal customer of Brenneco for several years, but my recent experience was highly disappointing. Misguided and Poor Follow-Up: After Brenneco's service, the remediation technician complained the water heater job was not done properly. I brought these concerns with Brenneco expecting them to hear me out and provide guidance. Instead, Becky asked me to share documentation and qualifications for the remediation technician—a misdirection that wasted my time and failed to address the actual issue. This approach felt dismissive and unhelpful. Decline in Service Standards: As a repeat customer, I expected the same high-quality service I received in the past. Unfortunately, this time, both technical work and customer support fell short of expectations. Inconsistent Discount Policy: As a returning customer, I was previously offered discounts on two occasions. However, I was recently informed that there is a "no-discount policy," which contradicts my past experiences. I hope they take this feedback seriously and work on improving their policies and service quality for future customers.

A
Alex Quinn

Tried to sell me a $2900 complete sump pump system replacement, when all I needed was a routine backup battery replacement. At the time, I was pretty clueless about how the system worked. Pump was working, but a warning light/sound was on. Plumber looked at it for

Business details

Phone
(765) 448-6190
Address
2780 Conservation Club Rd, Lafayette, IN 47905, USA
Hours
Varies — check website

Service area

Based in Lafayette. Serves 1 nearby cities within 20 miles:

Last updated June 25, 2026 · Data from Google Reviews
0

Brenneco Plumbing

4.8
Call