Best Water Heater Repair Pros in Greeley
#1Strong Hire
Finish Plumbing, LLC
5Water Heater Repair: 94/100
“Always dependable, explains clearly, clean and considerate.”
#2Strong Hire
Polar Bear Plumbing Heating & Air
5Water Heater Repair: 80/100
“Polar Bear had David dispatched to us the next morning and he patiently went through my options”
#3Conditional Hire
JT Plumbing Heating & Air
4.6Water Heater Repair: 80/100
“JT Plumbing withdrew the full $21,780 payment from our loan account more than a month before work began.”
All Water Heater Repair Pros in Greeley
Finish Plumbing, LLC
5·131 reviews·
20 mi away — Edge of service areaGoogle Verified
+7 more
Top pick5.0Google
Strengths
Emergency responsiveness: 8 reviews explicitly mention same-day,…
Pricing fairness: 11 reviews specifically praise reasonable,…
Workmanship quality: 9 reviews describe 'top notch,' 'excellent,'…
Communication and respect: 7 reviews praise clear explanations,…
Preliminary listing — full review analysis coming soon
Polar Bear Plumbing Heating & Air
5·585 reviews·
10 mi awayGoogle Verified
+3 more
Top pick5.0Google
Strengths
Same-day diagnose-and-repair on a furnace failure
Tankless water-heater retrofit (two old 40-gallon units)…
Saturday HVAC system replacement during a heat wave
Concerns
One reviewer notes pricing acknowledged as not the cheapest along…
JT Plumbing Heating & Air
4.6·1.3k reviews·
19 mi away — Edge of service areaGoogle Verified
Solid pick4.6Google
Strengths
Same-day water heater replacement after a sudden failure
Cleared a Saturday emergency clogged sewer within the hour
Replaced a collapsed main drain to septic same-day after…
Concerns
One Yelp report alleges high-pressure tactics using tariff and…
Displaced customer for 18 nights but only covered 8 in lodging…
Charged $820 for a garbage disposal job after a service window…
Yelp reviewer reports $21,780 withdrawn from loan account more…
Welzig Heating, Cooling, Plumbing & Electric
4.9·312 reviews·
20 mi away — Edge of service areaGoogle Verified
+2 more
Top pick4.9Google
Strengths
Thanksgiving-Day water-heater swap completed by 10:30 AM
2 AM furnace call answered with a tech on site by 9 AM
Comfort Club membership inspections catch issues early
Concerns
One Google reviewer reports a tech didn't recognize a yard…
Reviewer acknowledges they aren't the cheapest along the Front…
AAA Service Plumbing, Heating & Electric
4.9·578 reviews·
19 mi away — Edge of service areaGoogle Verified
+1 more
Solid pick4.9Google
Strengths
Sunday water-heater quote turnaround under 2 hours with Islom
Same-day dispatch on multiple calls
Sensor-package membership tracks system in real time and reviewer…
Concerns
Customer alleges Adam Nasser gutted an entire AC unit and…
Limelight Services
5·1.6k reviews·
14 mi away — Serves your areaGoogle Verified
+2 more
Top pick5.0Google
Strengths
Same-day basement leak rescue
Mini-split diagnostics
Sunday phone callback and scheduling confirmed
Concerns
Garbage disposal swap took longer than expected and review notes…
JT Plumbing Heating & Air
4.8·352 reviews·
19 mi away — Edge of service areaGoogle Verified
+2 more
Solid pick4.8Google
Strengths
Within-hours dispatch on a carbon-monoxide leak
Same-day arrival on a simple valve replacement;
Concerns
Yelp customer reports $21,780 withdrawn from loan account more…
Attempted upsell on a same-day valve repair
Lion Home Service
4.7·6.0k reviews·
19 mi away — Edge of service areaGoogle Verified
+5 more
Avoid4.7Google
Strengths
Sunday HVAC consultation followed by next-day install
Membership inspection program identified plumbing issues with…
Concerns
$29 diagnostic quoted on the phone became $200 on arrival for a…
Three-week wait for an electrician appointment that was no-showed…
Reviewer reports being charged multiple service fees over weeks…
Hose-bib replacement billed at $489 after $586 discount where…
Plumbline Services
4.8·1.2k reviews·
20 mi away — Edge of service areaGoogle Verified
+5 more
Solid pick4.8Google
Strengths
Technicians consistently described as professional,…
Fast response and same-day/next-day scheduling mentioned in 6…
Completion of major multi-system jobs (furnace + AC + humidifier)…
Thorough cleanup and respect for property consistently noted…
Concerns
Scheduling reliability gap: office missed appointment window…
Yelp rating of 2/5 (4 reviews) versus Google's 4.8/5 (1197…
Possible reluctance to take small jobs;
Roto Rooter
4·120 reviews·
In GreeleyGoogle Verified
+1 more
Avoid4.0Google
Strengths
8:45 PM emergency call answered with Shane on site within 15…
Sunday evening kitchen-sink backup answered the same day;
Sewer-line work and basement-flood toilet cleanups handled
Concerns
On-call plumber didn't answer phone twice for backed-up-sewage…
$7,000+ in repeat sewer charges over two years with the original…
Scheduled septic pumping no-show
Multiple reviewers report on-call techs not answering after-hours…
Common Water Heater Repair Scenarios
No Hot Water
Complete loss of hot water from a tank or tankless unit. Could be a failed heating element, thermostat, or gas valve issue.
Leaking Water Heater
Water pooling around the base of your tank is urgent — it can mean a failing tank that could rupture and flood your home.
Strange Noises or Smells
Popping, banging, or rumbling from your water heater signals sediment buildup. A sulfur smell may indicate a failing anode rod or gas leak.
Water Heater Replacement
Units over 10-12 years old that need frequent repairs are usually better replaced. Modern units are more efficient and reliable.
Frequently Asked Questions
How much does water heater repair cost in Greeley, CO?
Water heater repair in Greeley typically costs $150-$500 for common fixes like thermostat or element replacement. Full water heater replacement runs $1,200-$3,500 installed, depending on tank vs tankless and fuel type. Get multiple quotes from plumbers listed below.
Should I repair or replace my water heater?
If your water heater is over 10 years old and needs a repair costing more than $500, replacement is usually the better investment. Newer models are more energy-efficient and come with warranties. Plumbers in Greeley can help you evaluate the best option.
How long does water heater installation take?
A standard tank water heater replacement takes 2-4 hours. Tankless installations can take 4-8 hours due to additional venting and gas line work. Most plumbers in Weld County can complete same-day installation if the unit is in stock.
Can I get emergency water heater service in Greeley?
Yes — several plumbers serving Greeley offer same-day and emergency water heater repair. A leaking tank is urgent and should be addressed immediately to prevent water damage. Check the plumber ratings below for responsiveness scores.
Other Services in Greeley
Drain Cleaning Burst Pipe Repair Repiping Bathroom Remodel Plumbing Sewer Repair Sewer Line Replacement Toilet Repair Faucet Repair Garbage Disposal Repair Sump Pump Repair Gas Line Repair Slab Leak Repair Water Line Repair Kitchen Remodel Plumbing Hydro-Jetting 24-Hour Plumber Same-Day Plumber Affordable Plumber Licensed Plumber Plumber Cost Clogged Drain No Hot Water Water Leak Low Water Pressure Frozen Pipes Sewage Backup All Emergency Plumbers
Water Heater Repair in Nearby Cities
Need Water Heater Repair Right Now?
Call a top-rated water heater repair pro in Greeley.
Call Top-Rated Pro NowAre You a Plumber?
Get listed on Fast Plumber Near Me and connect with homeowners who need emergency plumbing help right now. Free basic listings available.