Toilet Repair in St. Matthews, KY
Toilet running or leaking? Find reliable toilet repair pros.
Jefferson County15 plumbers available
Best Toilet Repair Pros in St. Matthews
#1Strong Hire
St. Matthews Plumbing
4.9Toilet Repair: 75/100
“While fixing it correctly, they accidentally damaged the toilet flange. They told me about it immediately, and repaired it better than it was before (with no extra cost).”
#2Strong Hire
Overflow Plumbing, LLC
4.9Reviewed for toilet repair
“I have used Overflow Service for around 10 years now. They even replaced my City Water intake pipe, which fixed so many of my pressure and flow problems”
#3Conditional Hire
Roto-Rooter Plumbing & Water Cleanup
4.6Reviewed for toilet repair
“Dalton was at the house on time and was ready to go. He got right to work and was able to drive to town, about 13 minutes each way, get parts, and get the job done in under 2 hours”
All Toilet Repair Pros in St. Matthews
St. Matthews Plumbing
4.9·516 reviews·
In St. MatthewsGoogle Verified
+2 more
Top pick4.9Google
Strengths
Fast_response theme appears in 17 of 80 reviews;
Self-corrected mistakes at no charge
Christmas Eve toilet install completed before the holiday
Concerns
Initial recommendation of a new toilet flagged when augering the…
Overflow Plumbing, LLC
4.9·232 reviews·
In St. MatthewsGoogle Verified
+2 more
Top pick4.9Google
Strengths
Burst basement pipe repaired plus cleaned up same day at fair…
Tech team flagged a recurring frozen-pipe issue customer had…
Reviewers cite techs only charging the service fee when issues…
Concerns
Yelp rating of 3.0 across 2 reviews is too small a sample to be…
Roto-Rooter Plumbing & Water Cleanup
4.6·437 reviews·
7 mi awayGoogle Verified
+2 more
Solid pick4.6Google
Strengths
Sunday-morning dispatch for clogs confirmed by multiple reviewers
1am main-water-line break got a callback by 8am and on-site by…
Tech-level cleanup repeatedly mentioned: reviewers came home to…
Concerns
Not enough data to identify weaknesses
Dauenhauer Plumbing Heating Air & Electric
4.8·8.9k reviews·
5 mi awayGoogle Verified
+1 more
Solid pick4.8Google
Strengths
BBB accredited with A+ rating;
Multiple reviewers mention same-day response (toilet before…
Techs like Hunter and Hayden specifically called out for thorough…
Concerns
Two distinct property-damage allegations across plumbing (sump…
Another 1-star says AC install used wrong-sized liquid lines…
Golden Plumbing
4.8·438 reviews·
7 mi awayGoogle Verified
+2 more
Top pick4.8Google
Strengths
Multiple reviewers describe same-day arrival with named techs…
Specific praise for not upselling
Quick water heater installs cited at 45 minutes
Concerns
Allegation of unauthorized credit card use in a recent review
One reviewer reports a 2-day job that ran more than 2 months with…
A separate reviewer describes a $408 gas-leak fix that LG&E later…
Daniel Brown Plumbing
4.9·511 reviews·
9 mi awayGoogle Verified
+4 more
Top pick4.9Google
Strengths
All 30 sampled reviews are 5-star across both Google and Yelp
Multiple reviewers specifically note no pressure to add work or…
Whole-house leak detection and warranty-coordinated work both get…
BBB-accredited A+
Concerns
Not enough negative review data in this sample to identify…
Jarboe's Heating, Cooling & Plumbing
4.8·5.9k reviews·
In St. MatthewsGoogle Verified
+4 more
Avoid4.8Google
Strengths
Multiple 5-star reviewers praise sewer line replacement and…
Reviewers consistently note knowledgeable, friendly technicians…
Concerns
BBB accreditation is A+, but a 2.6-star gap between Google (4.8)…
Reports of unprofessional driver conduct off the job site appear…
Several 1-star reviewers describe waiting all day after being…
Multiple reviewers report aggressive upsells during routine…
Benjamin Franklin Plumbing
5·85 reviews·
In St. MatthewsGoogle Verified
+3 more
Top pick5.0Google
Strengths
Fast_response theme in 17 of 76 reviews;
Pricing transparency cited
After-hours emergency dispatch confirmed
Concerns
Not enough data to identify weaknesses
Maeser Master Services
4.8·5.4k reviews·
6 mi awayGoogle Verified
Proceed with care4.8Google
Strengths
Same-day arrival cited in 18 of 100 reviews;
Free diagnostic visits noted
Emergency sewer backup response in middle of the night handled…
Concerns
26 of 100 reviews are 1-star with sticker-shock estimates and…
Pricing complaints in 6 of 100 reviews
Refund/dispute resolution flagged
Queens Plumbing
5·54 reviews·
7 mi awayGoogle Verified
+4 more
Top pick5.0Google
Strengths
Owner Cody answered call while on vacation and diagnosed water…
Fair_pricing theme in 4 of 57 reviews;
After-hours responsiveness cited
Preliminary listing — full review analysis coming soon
1-Tom-Plumber
4.9·1.4k reviews·
In St. MatthewsGoogle Verified
+3 more
Solid pick4.9Google
Strengths
Exceptional emergency responsiveness: Multiple reviewers praise…
Consistently excellent workmanship across varied jobs (toilet…
Strong communication and transparency: 6 reviewers explicitly…
Professional crew demeanor: Multiple reviews highlight…
Concerns
Pricing variance: 2 of 8 Yelp reviews (25%) specifically mention…
One review reports technician declined to diagnose clogged sink…
Noah's Plumbing & Water Heaters
4.8·89 reviews·
In St. MatthewsGoogle Verified
Proceed with care4.8Google
Strengths
Water-heater service mentioned in 49 of 100 reviews;
Same-day dispatch in 19 of 100 reviews;
Weekend/Saturday dispatch confirmed
Concerns
One reviewer alleges this is a fake Google listing operated by a…
Manager named James Reesor flagged for disrespectful…
Quote-vs-final-bill discrepancy cited
Voicemail-full and no-callback complaints
Avantel Plumber of Louisville KY
5·13 reviews·
11 mi away — Serves your areaGoogle Verified
Solid pick5.0Google
Strengths
One reviewer reports on-site within an hour of calling
Late-night pipe burst handled per one reviewer
Water heater installation called out as fast and competent in one…
Concerns
Multiple reviews appear nearly identical or duplicated (same…
Review pool is small (13 Google, 0 Yelp) and reads as templated
Reviews use similar generic phrasing ('communication was solid',…
Graham's Plumbing Co. Inc.
4.8·95 reviews·
5 mi awayGoogle Verified
Proceed with care4.8Google
Strengths
Same-day dispatch within an hour cited
Quoted at half the price of competitors for shower valve…
Concerns
One reviewer reports harassing facebook messages and repeated…
12 of 100 reviews are 1-star with incomplete-work and…
Expensive theme in 4 of 100 reviews
Tom Drexler Plumbing, Air & Electric
4.8·21k reviews·
In St. MatthewsGoogle Verified
+5 more
Avoid4.8Google
Strengths
Quick emergency dispatch—multiple reviews confirm technicians…
Individual technicians occasionally deliver excellent service:…
Concerns
Extreme rating disparity: 4.8/5 on Google (20,925 reviews) vs…
No-show pattern during business hours with 'unexpected…
Predatory targeting: one review explicitly alleges the company…
Aggressive high-pressure sales: review documents senior customer…
Common Toilet Repair Scenarios
Running Toilet
A toilet that won't stop running wastes 200+ gallons per day. Usually caused by a worn flapper, faulty fill valve, or float adjustment issue.
Toilet Leak at Base
Water pooling around the base of your toilet usually means a failed wax ring seal. Left unfixed, it damages subfloor and can cause mold.
Clogged Toilet
When a plunger can't clear the blockage, there may be an obstruction deep in the trap or drain line that needs professional snaking.
Toilet Replacement
Old toilets using 3.5-7 gallons per flush should be replaced with modern 1.28 GPF models. Some municipalities offer rebates for water-efficient upgrades.
Frequently Asked Questions
How much does toilet repair cost in St. Matthews, KY?
Toilet repair in St. Matthews typically costs $100-$350. Running toilet fixes (flapper, fill valve) run $100-$200. Wax ring replacement costs $150-$300. Full toilet replacement with installation runs $300-$800 including the fixture. Labor is the main cost — the parts are inexpensive.
Should I repair or replace my toilet?
Repair if: it's a single issue like a running toilet or loose connection. Replace if: it's cracked, requires frequent repairs, uses more than 1.6 gallons per flush, or wobbles despite tightening. Modern toilets save 13,000+ gallons per year per household.
Can a running toilet increase my water bill?
Yes — a running toilet in your St. Matthews home can waste 200+ gallons per day, adding $100+ per month to your water bill. A $150 repair pays for itself within weeks. Don't ignore it.
How long does toilet installation take?
A standard toilet replacement takes 1-2 hours. If the flange needs repair or the floor has water damage, add 1-3 hours. Most plumbers in Jefferson County can do same-day toilet installation.
Other Services in St. Matthews
Drain Cleaning Water Heater Repair Burst Pipe Repair Repiping Bathroom Remodel Plumbing Sewer Repair Sewer Line Replacement Faucet Repair Garbage Disposal Repair Sump Pump Repair Gas Line Repair Slab Leak Repair Water Line Repair Kitchen Remodel Plumbing Hydro-Jetting 24-Hour Plumber Same-Day Plumber Affordable Plumber Licensed Plumber Plumber Cost Clogged Drain No Hot Water Water Leak Low Water Pressure Frozen Pipes Sewage Backup All Emergency Plumbers
Toilet Repair in Nearby Cities
Need Toilet Repair Right Now?
Call a top-rated toilet repair pro in St. Matthews.
Call Top-Rated Pro NowAre You a Plumber?
Get listed on Fast Plumber Near Me and connect with homeowners who need emergency plumbing help right now. Free basic listings available.