Blue Ridge Mountain Plumbing
Fast Response
Reviewers confirm quick response
Claims 24/7
Self-reported — not confirmed by reviews
Premium
Based on review analysis
3 concerns
1 of 5 reviews alleges serious ethical violation: diagnostically identifying a $300 trim kit repair to homeowner, then telling warranty company problem was undiagnosable, resulting in claim denial and customer having to fix issue themselves for $12, Avoidance behavior under accountability: company hung up on 3 way call when warranty company became involved, suggesting unwillingness to stand behind work when third party present, High score variance (38) and 3.6/5 Google rating despite 4 five star reviews suggests polarized customer experiences, particularly around warranty work
Trust Score: 0/100 · Based on 84 reviews
Our Verdict
#16 of 19 in Spotsylvania, VA
- Bathroom and kitchen remodel plumbing
- You're highly price-sensitive
Hire if: You need high-quality work that holds up over time
Hire if: You need a plumber who actually shows up when scheduled
Caution if: You need predictable, consistent service across every visit
Caution if: You need rock-bottom prices with zero flexibility on the quote
Caution if: You need detailed walkthroughs and written estimates before work starts
How they score across what matters
Based on 5 reviews analyzed. Click a row for the quote that best illustrates the score.
What they do well (and don’t)
Green means reviews confirm they’re good at it. Red means reviewers flag issues. Gray means no reviews talk about it yet.
What 84 Reviews Tell Us
Emergency Response
Responsive and punctual: 3 of 5 reviews specifically mention on-time arrival and quick problem resolution
What To Watch Out For
Severe communication breakdown with warranty companies: refused to answer calls from American Home Shield, hung up when warranty company joined call, and allegedly gave conflicting diagnoses to customer vs. insurer
Unresponsive to customer follow-up: when customer called multiple times seeking correction of warranty claim error, company would not help or return calls
Possible diagnostic misrepresentation: warranty claim review suggests plumber diagnosed problem to customer but told insurer problem could not be diagnosed, which customer disputes
1 of 5 reviews alleges serious ethical violation: diagnostically identifying a $300 trim kit repair to homeowner, then telling warranty company problem was undiagnosable, resulting in claim denial and customer having to fix issue themselves for $12
Avoidance behavior under accountability: company hung up on 3 way call when warranty company became involved, suggesting unwillingness to stand behind work when third party present
High score variance (38) and 3.6/5 Google rating despite 4 five star reviews suggests polarized customer experiences, particularly around warranty work
Quality & Professionalism
Strong workmanship: multiple reviewers praise quality of repairs and willingness to fix problems other companies missed or misdiagnosed
Strong communication and customer service with direct clients: reviewers highlight listening to concerns, explaining work, and professional courtesy
Communication
Responsive and punctual: 3 of 5 reviews specifically mention on-time arrival and quick problem resolution
Strong communication and customer service with direct clients: reviewers highlight listening to concerns, explaining work, and professional courtesy
Severe communication breakdown with warranty companies: refused to answer calls from American Home Shield, hung up when warranty company joined call, and allegedly gave conflicting diagnoses to customer vs. insurer
Unresponsive to customer follow-up: when customer called multiple times seeking correction of warranty claim error, company would not help or return calls
Pricing
Competitive pricing on direct jobs: reviewers note prices 'well below' big companies when not involving warranty claims
Customer reviews
Reviews from Google, Yelp & more
Promptly resolves issues with exceptional professionalism and extensive knowledge. Provides outstanding customer service.
Blue Ridge Mountain Plumbing was the BEST experience that I have EVER had in dealing with a professional plumbing service. When I called to schedule my appointment, Joshua, the office manager actually LISTENED to my concerns and I immediately knew that I was in excellent hands. Jonathan, the plumber showed up and IMMEDIATELY fixed the problem that another plumbing company neglected to fix. I read the previous reviews and I must say that being a new company, so many of us are impatient these days and expect service immediately. After going through another company who was extremely dishonest, I will gladly wait for an HONEST, RELIABLE company like Blue Ridge Mountain Plumbing to fix ALL of my plumbing issues in the future. I just wanted to extend a heartfelt thank you to Joshua & Jonathan for turning my nightmare of an experience completely around and actually making this customer a believer in good customer service! Please give Blue Ridge Mountain Plumbing a call, I promise you won't be disappointed.
Blue Ridge Mountain exceeded my expectations! They arrived on time. Made adjustments to the work as needed (because I didn't think to include a second outlet for the washer to the work needed). They took the time to explain everything to me. They were professional and curtious and thorough with the work. I will use them again and will recommend them to friends and family. I have seen some negative reviews on here and have also notice they all include a home warranty company. Because of my personal experience with home warranty companies, I will not hold Blue Ridge Mountain Plumbing accountable for those reviews.
American Home Shield Home Warranty assigned Blue Ridge Mountain Plumbing to repair a faucet in my house. When the plumbers showed up they diagnosed the problem, and told me the faucet needed a trim kit replaced. Normally a $300 fee. But the plumbers told American Home Shield that they could not diagnose the problem. So American Home Shield denied the claim. How can you diagnose the problem, and not be able to diagnose the problem, at the same time? I called Blue Ridge Mountain Plumbing several times asking them to fix the error. They would not help me. American Home Shield tried to call them multiple times, but they would not answer the phone or return calls. So I initiated a 3-way call with American Home Shield and Blue Ridge Mointain Plumbing. As soon as the Plumbing company associate realized American Home Shield was also on the call... CLICK... they hung up. That's interesting... Why did the plumbing company refuse to tell the warranty company about their error? Why would they refuse to even talk to them? Why wouldn't they talk to me? HORRIBLE CUSTOMER SERVICE. JERKS. If you don't want to do contract work for home warranty companies, then get off of their list of contractors. Finally last week a friend of mine looked at my faucet, went to Lowe's, bought a $12 handle, installed it in five minutes, and now it works great! No trim kit needed after all. It makes me sick when contractors take advantage of home owners' lack of knowledge and try to screw them over. Disgusting. ------ MY REPLY TO YOUR REPLY: American Home Shield denied my claim BECAUSE YOU LIED AND TOLD THEM YOU COULD NOT DIAGNOSE THE PROBLEM. You just admitted that it needed a trim kit, THAT IS A DIAGNOSIS. And as you read in my review, I DID CALL the warranty company. But you WOULDN'T answer their calls. Why did you hang up when you realized they were on a 3-way call with us??? Answer those questions please.
James from Blue Ridge Mountain Plumbing installed a propane tank for our fireplace in a home that we recently purchased. This is one of the only companies that I could find where you actually own the tank and are not locked into a fuel delivery contract. During the clean and inspect they found that the pilot assembly was not in working order. (not surprising since you could tell no maintenance had ever been done). James had us up and running in no time and at a price that was well below what the "BIG" companies charge. I recommend them to anyone looking for fireplace or plumbing service.
Business details
Service area
Based in Spotsylvania. Serves 1 nearby cities within 20 miles:
Blue Ridge Mountain Plumbing